Ideas:
The Bank of Japan seems to always be less than transparent it its communication because the don't want to cause harm to the financial markets so they are usually not so clear sometimes one what they are going to do.
They would rather keep the markets guessing instead of saying something directly that might cause harm. This of course not being direct can backfire with the markets not sure that to do sometimes.
If inflation is really slowing down, that might be a reason, in pure central market strategies to not increase the key rate.
And again, if import costs too are calming down, that too might be a reason to just let the weak stay as it is as it benefits many in Japan.
The economist might think there are no factors, but what happens exactly in the BOJ meetings sometimes is hard to know and the meeting notes that is given to the public might not be what actually is talked about in the meetings.
Perhaps the Bank of Japan is both a dove and a hawk, depending on the mood at the time of the meeting and at the same time, maybe they can't makeup their minds about what do to.
And the reason for that, again, is they don't want to cause any harm to the financial markets so many times they just take a wait and see approach.
Many times what is said in one meeting might be thought of as a mistake and so they next meeting the BOJ officials might say something completely different.
And economic conditions change from one meeting to the next so the economic conditions just before one meeting might be completely different just before the next BOJ meeting.
Central banks don't have to do anything other than watch the economy and makes adjustments as needed. If they think no adjustments are needed they don't have to do anything.
Its not uncommon for central banks to say one thing in one meeting and say the complete opposite in the next meeting, as they might have seen some new data that changed their point of view.
Its sound like again, the financial markets are hanging on every word that the Bank of Japan says instead of just completely waiting to see if the rate will be increased or not instead of jumping to predictions ahead of meetings.
Waiting for more data, might be true or, again, it just an expression when the BOJ doesn't know what to do and is waiting for another time to increase the rate.
The next rate hike might be in March, as yes, the BOJ is waiting to see what will happen in the wage negotiations coming up next year.
Wage increases seem to be on the mind of the Bank of Japan as to what they are going to do. If the wage increases are big enough for the Bank of Japan, that might be a sign that they are going to increase the key rate.
The BOJ might need to improve communication but it must be remembered they are very cautious about what they say, usually, and they don't want to say anything, again, that might upset the financial markets in Japan and globally.
The Bank of Japan's moves have not been wild swings as the BOJ has only made two key rate changes and they were very small. Yes, they might buy a lot of bonds to pump up the Japanese economy but they have been doing that for a very long time.
Key economic indicators might be in line with BOJ's expectations but as new data comes out in the future the BOJ could easily, like they seemed to do often do, delay any rate hikes until they examine the data more carefully.
Most central banks are supposed to be independent from any political party or situation, supposedly free to manage the economy as needed. But in reality that might not be true, and even in Japan the Bank of Japan might be influence by political situations.
Such as the situation with the disposable income situation and allowing more working hours for part-time workers without having to pay income taxes, with an key interest rate increase may or may not have an affect on part-time workers.
Yes, even young married families who have mortgages could be significantly affected by rate hikes especially if the mother in the family works part-time and the rate hike could wipe out what the wife makes dues to an increase in mortgage rates.
So, again, the Bank of Japan has to look at all situations including any political situations can might affect the Japanese economy such the disposable income tax benefit for young families and part-time workers.
The Bank of Japan as to weigh a lot of variables that affect the Japanese economy, such there are some positive benefits to a weak yen in Japan, such it helps Japanese export companies along with helping Japanese investors overseas, and then there is the idea that a weak yen, might be a reason for the record number of foreign tourists who go to Japan and spend a lot as they have more purchasing power due to the weak yen.
And then there is the weak yen on the domestic economy and importers as Japan is resource poor country and has to import much of what it needs which means import prices are higher than normal and importers will pass-on their import costs to the next in the supply chain including the final customer.
The Bank of Japan rate hike was as big surprise to the Japanese financial markets which kind of went crazy for a few days with their disapproval that they basically were not warned of the rate hike.
The Bank of Japan needs to be very careful as all financial markets, even globally, react to anything and everything good or not so good.
And rate hike might not affect or cause inflation to decrease immediately as it could take months for anything happens in an economy.
Whatever happens with the Bank of Japan there are those who like a rate increase and those who don't like a rate increase so the Bank of Japan is in a no-win situation whatever it does.
And again the Japanese yen might weaken of strengthen either way so in a way the Bank of Japan increasing the rate might not have much of an affect on the weak yen getting weaker.
And yes the timing of a rate hike is very important and even more important is the communication before a rate hike, as again the markets are very volatile and react to anything.
Yes, Ueda might need to see what is going to happen with the wage increases in April of 2025, and if they increases are not to his liking he might again take a wait and see approach.
The key might not be large Japanese companies who most likely will give the needed wage increases that Ueda wants to see, but the challenge is what is going to happen with small and midsize companies, which employ about 70 percent of the Japanese workforce, and if they don't or can't increases wages as much as the large companies it could be challenge for the Bank of Japan and Ueda.
Have a nice day!