Japan's consumption tax suspension may not result in lower food prices
Ideas
Of course it might be a good idea to suspend the consumer or consumer tax on food but there are more inflation variables that are causing high food prices that need to be looked at carefully.
The consumption tax, in the beginning, was always a way to try and reduce the high Japanese government debt, but who really knows what the motivation is now help Japanese households.
The current Prime Minister, like her late mentor, the late Prime Minister ABE is seen as a economic dove, meaning she is trying to help and improve the economy, even though she is a hard-line right leaning politician.
Yes, if the consumer or consumption tax is suspended some businesses might see it as an opportunity to pass-on their costs due the weak Japanese yen, and they feel that have more room to do it and maybe might think consumers might not notice.
If it takes until the fall to implement the tax suspension, that might be too long to wait for many Japanese households as some consumers and households in Japan continues to feel the affects of the consumption tax.
Even though the rate of tax on food remained at 8 percent that was/is not good for the lower-income groups in Japan such as fixed income retirees, part-time workers, contract workers, and anyone else whose income isn't good enough to not feel the affects of the consumption food tax.
Its understandable that some consumers are wary of cheaper goods, as maybe some companies, such as small and mid-sized companies, might be trying to find ways to offer substitutes or alternatives to high-priced quality products.
The problem is not so much that the cheaper products are not good quality products but its the perception that some consumers might have about food products that might not cost as much as higher priced products.
Of course many small and mid-size companies are wary of passing-on their costs due to the fact that either they don't want to to lose any customers and or the possibility that if they are a a supplier to large companies the large companies are objecting the smaller companies passing-on their costs and might actually lose their contract with the larger companies.
Yes, the profit margins of small companies are just too thin and if they try to reduce their prices by as much as 8 percent they might not have any room to make any kind of profit and could be forced out of business.
And yes, it's natural that some companies will take advantage and increase prices due increased material costs, logistics, and labor costs if the 8 percent consumption tax is reduced or suspended.
Yes, each country has its own examples, both positives and negatives of how a consumption tax can increase or decrease prices but they need to be examined more carefully as again there might be many variables that can affect price increases and or price decreases.
The examples need to be taken with a grain of salt or not taken literally as there again are just too many variables involved that can cause increases or decreases in food prices.
Again, each country has its own story related to increases and decreases in food prices and again there are just too many variable, both known and unknown, that might be affecting food prices.
At the same time, as its been suggested again, some in Japan might not even notice a decrease or increase in the consumption tax as they just don't or feel it very much, but for sure there are many who do feel the increase or decrease in food prices.
Yes, at this point its unclear what companies are going to do if the consumption tax is suspended or even reduced to 5 percent or less. Are companies going to increase or decrease prices and think they might be able to get away with it and some might think Japanese households might not notice much a change.
Companies could be under pressure not to increase prices as they feel their profit margins are just too thin and need more room to operate if the consumption tax is suspended.
But some companies might not have any choice as a market economy is for the most part have reduced government influence as companies are free to do what they think is best for them and hopefully good for consumers and society too.
Have a nice day!