Editorial: Gov't, businesses' neglect of people has cost Japan 30 years of stagnation
It has been suggested that Japan grew too fast after WW11, especially in the 70's and 80's and maybe Japan became too arrogant about its growth rate, didn't really focus on building a foundation for the future, instead just focused on market share for growth.
An economy is very complicated and there are no easy answers to grow an economy and or restore an economy, which Japan is now tasked with doing.
China might making the same mistakes as Japan has had and maybe take some time to restores its economy too.
Wages are only given once a year, in April, while inflation is a daily/weekly situation that keeps increasing.
Household spending or consumer spending in Japan is always a challenge and the Japanese, for the most part, have always been more savers than spenders compared to US consumers.
At one time, maybe in the 60's and 70's, and maybe the 80's too. Peter Drucker, the late management expert used to go to Japan every year and give seminars about business and management, and Japan companies revered him for his ideas.
What Drucker usually talked about, related to Japan, was Japan's emphasis on its human capital and how Japanese companies saw employees as key stakeholders, meaning workers were very important to Japanese companies, and at the time not just a commodity to be used and laid-off, when needed.
But those days seem a long time ago, and Japanese companies seemed to have become too westernized with their emphasis now on short-term results and thinking only of shareholders and not employees still as stakeholders.
Long-term plans or goals used to be the trademark of Japanese companies and they weren't too focused on short-term goals to keep stockholders happy, and again, those days seem a long time ago.
There might be a multitude of variables as to why Japan has not kept up in the world and maybe those mentioned are some keys to what has happened to Japan.
Perhaps, again, Japanese companies became too arrogant in the 1980's as there were many articles written that Japan would overtake the US and the number one economy in the world.
Well, it never happened and Japan has gone backwards for its heyday of the 1980's, and no company shows it more than Sony and or Japan's smartphone companies which have failed to keep up with Apple or Samsung.
Again, how many Japanese smartphones are among the market share leaders around the world? None, as Apple, Samsung, and maybe some Chinese companies are the market leaders these days, and Japanese smartphone companies only sell in Japan.
What was a key trademark for Japanese companies was developing in-company talent, but again those days were wasted as talent development became a secondary matter to keeping shareholders happy in a company.
Again, an economy is very complex and Japan, good or not so good, tried many things, that they thought was in the best interest of Japan. Most of course didn't work, but for the most part, didn't bring real harm to the economy, but just kept the economy in a semi-stagnation situation for a very long time.
Abenomics, at the time, seemed like the answer to get the economy out of stagnation situation, but maybe the Japanese economy was in such a hole, that not even Abenomics was going to get it going.
Its only natural that governments try to use fiscal stimulus packages to get the economy moving again, but they should be used sparingly and not continuously, as Japan has tried to do, and because they were used so much, they might have lost their affect on the Japanese economy.
Consumer sentiment seems to be in a deep dive or deep hole for a very long time as Japanese households and consumers lost hope in the Japanese economy ever being what it once was when it was more like free-wheeling free-spending economy of the 1980's.
That is the problem and challenges of monetary policy. Policy seems to help some in an economy and not help others in an economy and maybe even harm some.
For example, a weak yen helps exporters but hurts importers and the domestic economy, but again, its almost impossible to help each and ever sector in an economy with the same monetary policy.
Monetary policy decision makers have to make a choice and unfortunately, its the Japanese middle class that didn't really benefit from Abenomics, preferring to favor Japanese export companies such as Toyota and those affluent in Japanese society and business.
And yes, government spending became the norm at the time to try and lift the Japanese economy out if its stagnation situation.
Its seems the risk takers of the 60's, 70's, an 80's lost their drive after the Japan economy crashed around 1989/1990, and many of these risk takers either retired and or new management and CEO's were just content with the status quo.
It was at that time, that many Japanese companies started to re-structure and move more toward western style financial management and putting more emphasis on stockholder/shareholders and not so much on workers as important stakeholders in the company.
The entire Japanese economy and society had drifted into a just get by stagnation and the drive and risk-taking of the 60's, 70's, and 80's had been lost by all.
By now, maybe its going to be impossible to completely re-structure the entire Japanese economy, as maybe many young workers just don't have the needed drive and maybe many companies don't have the initiative to do the required restructuring.
And again, the focus seems to be only on shareholder value and not employee stakeholder empowerment, which can go a long way toward lifting up the middle class and also increasing consumer spending in the Japanese economy.
And maybe no-one really cares that Japan has fallen to 3rd, 4th, and 5th as an economy, an even more it terms of per-capita income.
Conclusion: This article might have been deleted from the main webpage as maybe it caused too much friction with the idea that both the Japanese government and Japanese companies were the main players that didn't do much to improve the economy, over 30 years.
But to be fair, Japanese government and the Bank of Japan policy makers tried to do what they thought was best for the Japanese economy at the time.
Again, an economy is very complex and has many moving parts that can't always be fixed or managed at the same time, Policy makers have to makes decision, and they know there are going to be side-effect with whatever they try to do.
Have a nice day and be safe!