Article Source: https://mainichi.jp/english/articles/20220429/p2g/00m/0bu/002000c
Article:
TOKYO (Kyodo) -- The Bank of Japan's steadfast commitment to a loose monetary policy coupled with the authorities' inability to stem the yen's slide could send the Japanese currency to its weakest level in more than 20 years against the U.S. dollar.
Falling below 130 yen against the dollar Thursday after the central bank left its ultraeasy monetary policy unchanged, market analysts expect the yen to test the downside toward 135.15, a level not seen since Jan. 31, 2002. Once this support is breached, the next downside target is expected at 136.05, set in October 1998.
The yen has fallen about 15 yen, or 13 percent, to 20-year lows against the greenback since early March. A weaker yen traditionally benefits Japan's export-oriented economy. However, it is now hurting the resource-scarce country, battling surging energy and commodity prices.
Ideas:
The yen may continue to weak and its looks like the BOJ has no plans to depart from its current policy of a loose monetery policy,
Japan's economy is just not strong enough to handle a key rate increase because all of the side effects to an rate increase might be too much for the already weak economy.
The BOJ and the Japanese economy might have no choice but to just ride out the weak yen and then add some measures to help those households and businesses reeling from the weak yen
A rate increase might just make matters worse on already no so good conditions for the Japanese economy.
Article:
The weakening of the Japanese currency reflects the view among market participants that the BOJ will lag central banks in other major economies in normalizing monetary policy.
The BOJ also said after its regular two-day meeting that ended Thursday that it will carry out a fixed-rate government bond-buying operation "every business day" to stem a rise in the benchmark 10-year yield above its allowed limit.
In contrast, the U.S. Federal Reserve is expected to raise interest rates by 0.5 percentage point at its upcoming May 3-4 meeting. The incremental jump would be larger than the central bank's typical quarter-point increase as it tries to stem the fastest inflation the nation has seen in more than 40 years.
Ideas:
The Bank of Japan needs to stand its ground and not be pressured by other central banks. Each economy is a differnt organism and the Japanease economy is not the same as the US or the EU.
Japan's Q1 GDP was -0.1 percent which is not a good indicator of an economy that is ready or able to handle any kind of rate increase.
The US economy is in much better shape than the Japaneae economy and as such might be able to handle some rate increases.
So is the Japanese economy an inferior economy because its weak and its growth doesn't match the US? Its a different situation but still equal to the US.
Different economies need different strategies to manage and fix discrepencies. What works in the US might not work in Japan, and what works in Japan might not work in the US.
Article:
"The quickest way to stop the yen's fall is for the BOJ to normalize its monetary policy or for the (Fed) not to pursue interest rate hikes -- both of which are unrealistic at the moment," said Takuya Kanda, senior researcher at Gaitame.com Research Institute.
Demand for the currency of a country offering higher bond yields is often stronger. The yield on Japan's benchmark 10-year government bonds has stayed around 0.25 percent recently, compared to close to 3 percent for the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield as the policies of the Japanese and U.S. central banks continue to diverge.
The BOJ aims to attain its 2 percent inflation target through its easing policy. Governor Haruhiko Kuroda has reiterated that the bank needs to continue the nearly decade-old policy, as the inflation seen in Japan has come from surging raw material prices and lacks sustainability.
Ideas:
Its unrealistic for the US to follow what Japan is doing and its equally unrealistic for Japan to follow what the US is doing at this time.
Higher yield bonds might helpe stabalize the yen some but not completely, as the rate might be a little too low at 0.25 compared to the US at near 3 percent. Perhaps in this situation Japan and the US could be a little closer in their bond yield rates.
The BOJ's goal of 2 percent inflation is still a realistic goal but for now it might not be doable as the type of inflation the BOJ wants is more related to consumer demand inflation and not supplier cost inflation.
Just how and when supplier inflation is going to slow down is the major question to be asked now. It would be nice to know just what does the BOJ know related to when supplier inflation is going to slow down or each its plateau level.
Article:
"Many investors have priced in the fact that the Fed is likely to accelerate its rate hikes and reduce its balance sheet," said Yukio Ishizuki, a senior foreign exchange strategist at Daiwa Securities Co.
Still, the governor and Finance Minister Shunichi Suzuki have warned that the rapid pace of the yen's fall is undesirable. Kuroda has said the yen's sharp fluctuations can cause trouble for companies making business plans.
"It's desirable that currency moves are stable, reflecting both economic and financial fundamentals," Kuroda said in a press conference after Thursday's meeting. "We will be watching the impact of currency moves on the economy and prices very carefully."
Ideas:
Yes, the rapid decrease of the yen is not good overall but again Japan might not have a choice at this moment and just try to ride the falling yen and at the same time find ways to help companies and households overcome the challenges related to a weak yen.
Fluctuations are never good. Fluctuations are constant increases and decreases in whatever and businesses for the most part can't plan when the yen, for example moves up or down a lot.
If the yen was steadily up or down businesses could prepare for one way to the other. But in this situation fluctuations might be considered constanstly moving up or down too fast, meaning companies don't have enough time to prepare for the steady fall of the yen.
Maybe the Japanese government, if they haven't decide yet, could provide a supplementary budget just to help businesses and households throught the weak yen period.
Article:
Their warnings have had little impact as market participants reckon there is a slim chance that the Finance Ministry will actually intervene in the currency market.
"It's become clear that verbal interventions don't make any difference, as investors see it as 'all words, no action,'" Kanda at Gaitame.com Research Institute said.
Japan posted the largest trade deficit in seven years in the fiscal year ended March 2022, as a surge in energy prices boosted imports with eight consecutive months of a deficit from August.
Ideas:
The BOJ needs to use its communication tools in a way to keep whomever satisifed, if possible, that its doing all it can at this time to make sure the Japanese economy is sound.
There is only so much a central bank can do or even the government side can do with fiscal strategies.
For example its not ther BOJ's fault or the Japanese government's fault that global energy prices or raw material prices are constantly increasing.
All the BOJ can do it try to manage the economy and try not to do too much harm. In this situation, because of the weakenesses in the Japan economy, increasing the key rate might actually do more harm than good at this time.
Any time there is a trade deficit, imports are more than exports. And this situation, the value of imports might be more than the value of exports because of the constant increase in global energy prices.
As Japan is more of an export oriented country there is always the concern about trade deficits or trade surpluses. A trade deficit reduces Japan's current account balance, kind of like a contry's bank account.
But Japan over many years ran trade surpluses meaning there were many years of the yen going into the account. So even though eight months might sound like a lot, when you have many years of a surplus even one year of deficits is not going make that big of an impact on Japan's current account.
Article:
As long as demand for the dollar from importers remains strong trade-wise, attempts by the authorities to arrest the yen's tumble will prove short-lived, analysts say.
"Balance in currency demand has skewered as importers have constantly been buying the dollar, with that need unlikely to end as long as soaring commodity and energy prices don't fall," said Ishizuki.
The BOJ could ask other central banks to step into the market in concerted efforts. Other countries, however, look little interested in the yen's recent rapid depreciation as they are focusing on curbing inflation and mitigating the impact of the Ukraine crisis, analysts say.d
Ideas:
All countries right now are most likely concerned with their own inflation challenges and might not be very interested in intervning in the currency market to help another country at this time.
There might be the possibility of some kind of currency swap in the near future as central banks always talk to each other related to swapping currencies as needed.
There seems to be too many distractions at this time for any country to be concerend with what is happeing in another country's economy.
At one time, for example, the US would sometimes say they weren't going to increase its rate because it might have an effect on other economies globally.
But maybe at this time the inflation situation and other challenges in the US has not allowed them to think globally but only think domestically about the US economy only at this time.
As long as energy prices and raw material prices continue to increase, importers in Japan are going to continue to buy dollars to protect their businesses.
Article:
With the House of Councillors election scheduled for the summer in Japan, voters are likely to focus on some of the factors that have recently pressured consumer spending, including elevated commodity prices and the yen's rapid depreciation, and how the government plans to mitigate those risks.
"It's not about when the yen might begin to strengthen again," Kanda said. "It's about how far it will fall."
Ideas:
Unfortunately economics and politics can be intertwined meaning anytime there is some kind of election politicians, whether good or bad find ways to say things that they think might help them win elections.
Whether they actually act on what they say is another story all together. But in this situation, it might be a good idea to say what they might do the manage or fix the current situation related to society and economy, and the continued in increase in prices.
Some might say "just let the economy fix itself," meaning let the economy be and it will naturally get back to some kind of normal or prices will get back to some kind of normal.
That might be happen eventually but how long is it going to take and how many businesses and households have to suffer through the higher prices.
Perhaps its time for some kind of subsidies or some kind of extra budget to be used as way to offset the higher prices.
The Bank of Japan and the Japanese government need to work together and come up with some strategies that can ease the burden on businesses and households.
Have a nice day and be safe!